Put both offers on the same timeline. Compare fixed pre-tax cash first, then record the dates and conditions for bonuses, equity, and benefits. The housing provident fund rules below apply to Beijing, mainland China, from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027. For another location or contribution year, verify the applicable rules before using those figures.
Seven-item offer comparison worksheet
Prepared by FermatMind Editorial. Comparison period: ____ to ____. Housing fund location, if applicable: A ____ / B ____.
| What to record | Offer A | Offer B |
|---|---|---|
| Base pay: monthly rate × paid months; note probation and partial months | ____ | ____ |
| Performance bonus: guarantee, target, payout date | ____ | ____ |
| Signing bonus: amount, payout, repayment | ____ | ____ |
| Equity: units and first vesting date | ____ | ____ |
| Fixed allowance: amount and whether included in salary | ____ | ____ |
| Reimbursements: caps and rules | ____ | ____ |
| Housing fund: base, both rates, start month | ____ | ____ |
Fixed pre-tax cash = base pay for the period + fixed allowances not already included. Attach the conditions to each bonus. Record employee and employer housing fund deposits separately. Leave unconfirmed amounts blank until HR answers.
Worked example: how much could each offer pay in the first year?
This example is fictional. Both employers are in Beijing, mainland China. Both offers have a January start date in the same year, and the comparison covers the first 12 full payroll months after starting. Assume full pay during probation and no partial months. Bonuses are paid as indicated only if their conditions are met. The housing fund calculation assumes 12 months at the same confirmed base and rates. Recalculate month by month if registration timing, the contribution year, or the applicable base changes. All amounts are in Chinese yuan (CNY), before tax. This is neither a payslip nor a take-home pay estimate.
| Component | Offer A | Offer B | What to verify |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base pay | 26,000 × 12 = 312,000 | 24,000 × 12 = 288,000 | Whether pay is before or after tax, whether probation or the first month is prorated, and whether any 13th-month payment has conditions or a set date. |
| Performance bonus | Target 36,000, not guaranteed | Target 12,000, not guaranteed | Individual and company targets, first-year proration, and whether you must still be employed on the payout date. |
| Signing bonus | None | 20,000 in month 3, potentially repayable if you leave early | Payment date, required service period, repayment triggers, and how the amount due is calculated. |
| Equity | Quoted reference value of 80,000, vesting in batches over four years; first tranche valued at 20,000 for illustration | None | Grant documents, first vesting date, conditions, liquidity, fees, and departure rules. For options, also check the exercise price. |
| Fixed allowance | None | 1,500 × 12 = 18,000 | Whether it is paid with salary and is on top of the 24,000, and whether attendance or location conditions apply. |
| Expense benefits | Actual transport expenses, capped at 300/month | Actual meal expenses, capped at 600/month | Without eligible spending, reimbursement is zero. List non-cash benefits such as supplemental insurance separately and estimate what you would actually use. |
| Housing fund | Assumed confirmed base 26,000; employee and employer each contribute 7% | Assumed confirmed base 24,000; employee and employer each contribute 12% | The base that applies in your first month, both rates, when contributions start, and how they may change. These bases are assumptions for the example. |
Check whether monthly salary already includes an allowance. If a recruitment email says “24,000 a month, including a 1,500 transport allowance,” the separate entries are 22,500 in base pay and 1,500 in allowance. Do not add 1,500 to the 24,000 again. If an offer says “target annual pay of 360,000 including performance pay,” ask HR to separate the fixed, target, and maximum figures before comparing it with the other offer. Similar benefit labels can also mean very different things. A meal card, reimbursement for commuting, and a cash meal allowance differ in how freely you can use them.
Run two cash scenarios and keep housing fund deposits and equity separate
Add base pay and confirmed fixed cash allowances. A comes to 312,000 and B to 306,000. Before either performance bonus or B's potentially repayable signing payment, A offers 6,000 more in fixed pre-tax cash. If B's allowance is actually conditional reimbursement, B's fixed cash drops to 288,000 and the difference grows to 24,000.
Now assume the target bonuses are paid within the comparison period and B's signing bonus arrives within it. A comes to 348,000 and B to 338,000, a difference of 10,000. Even after B's signing bonus arrives, a repayment clause may still apply. Track the money separately and consider leaving it out of your spending budget while it is at risk. Put the first performance bonus date on your timeline. A bonus earned for year-one work does not pay this year's rent if the employer pays it in year two. Even with a written amount, check whether it is a target, a guaranteed minimum, or an estimate under specified conditions.
| Decision figure | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed pre-tax cash, excluding conditional items | 312,000 | 306,000 |
| Target bonus paid within the period, plus any signing bonus paid on schedule | 348,000 | 338,000 |
| Reference value of first equity tranche | 20,000, shown separately and not yet realized | 0 |
| Maximum annual expense reimbursement | 3,600, subject to eligible spending | 7,200, subject to eligible spending |
For equity, write down the type of award, number of units, and vesting dates you can verify. If HR says “valued at 80,000,” distinguish the reference value on the grant date, how many units vest in year one, and whether you will have a way to sell them. Keep the cash totals unchanged while details are missing. You can likewise estimate a practical value for a benefit you would use. If eligible transport costs are 120 per month, for instance, the annual amount for your own comparison is at most 1,440. Keep that benefit separate from cash even if it matters to you.
Check the contribution base, both rates, and the months covered
For each party, multiply the applicable contribution base by its contribution rate. Then check local rules, rounding, and what the employer actually files. In the example, A is 26,000 × 7% = 1,820 per party per month. B is 24,000 × 12% = 2,880 per party per month. The combined deposits are 3,640 a month for A and 5,760 for B. Over the assumed 12 months, the account receives 43,680 and 69,120 respectively. B deposits 25,440 more. 12,720 comes from B's higher employee contribution and the remaining 12,720 is the difference in employer contributions.
The employee share comes out of your pay. If your fixed cash figure already includes your full gross pay, adding the employee contribution to “what the company pays me” counts part of it twice. Show the employer contribution separately as an employer-funded benefit. For spendable cash, use the net amount on an actual payslip. If you haven’t received one yet, start with the gross cash amount and deduct the applicable employee contributions, income tax, and other deductions once. The housing fund has withdrawal and use conditions. Keep account deposits separate from wages you can spend freely.
For Beijing, the Beijing Housing Provident Fund Management Center's 2026 annual notice covers July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027. It lists contribution rates of 5%–12%, a monthly contribution-base ceiling of CNY 36,348, and a general floor of CNY 2,540. Workers receiving a basic living allowance are subject to a separate rule. These figures describe Beijing's contribution year. To find the base and start month for a given employee, check their employment status, employer filing, and the rules then in effect. The example uses fictional confirmed bases and rates, so it does not imply that all employers use these rates. Check the applicable rules separately for a change of contribution year, a transfer from another location, a first job, or a different probation arrangement. Beijing Housing Provident Fund Management Center notice
Find the amount that would change your decision
The same offer can look different on a monthly budget and on an annual comparison. Take the fictional offers above. Suppose the candidate has planned for daily expenses and wants to know how much they might regularly set aside. In a normal payroll month, A's fixed pre-tax cash is 26,000 and B's is 25,500. After the assumed employee housing fund deduction alone, A has 24,180 and B has 22,620, a difference of 1,560 a month. Social insurance, income tax, and other deductions are still to come. This line shows the effect of the housing fund deduction, not spendable pay. If a rental deposit is due before month three, B's eventual signing bonus only helps if its actual payment date is early enough.
| If the written terms change | What to recalculate | Revised comparison |
|---|---|---|
| B pays the annual bonus in month 14 | Move it outside the first 12 months | If the other assumptions hold and the signing bonus is paid as agreed, B’s year-one cash is 326,000. Record the expected 12,000 payment in month 14 separately. |
| B pays 90% of base for three probation months, with the allowance unchanged | Deduct 24,000 × 10% × 3 = 7,200 from fixed pay | B falls to 298,800 in fixed cash. A stays at 312,000. This does not estimate a change in the contribution base. |
| A's first equity tranche vests just after year one ends | Move it past the comparison window | Keep the grant details on record. Fixed cash is unchanged, and the reference value does not enter first-year realizable income. |
| B contributes from month two at the example rates, while A contributes for 12 months | Recalculate B for 11 months | B deposits 63,360 and A 43,680. The start month is an example input, not a rule for all local hires. |
Apply these changes together only if the employer confirms they all occur together. If year-one pay is deferred until year two and requires you to remain employed on a particular date, enter the date, condition, and amount separately as a deferred payment. This affects timing and the chance of receiving the money. A lower stated offer instead changes the amount payable for the whole period. When a performance period and payment date differ, record both the period the work relates to and the date payment could arrive.
Calculate the break-even amount before asking HR
In the original example, A comes to 348,000 if the target bonus is paid within the period. B comes to 338,000 if both its target and signing bonuses arrive within it. If A pays no bonus but B pays both, B exceeds A's 312,000 by 26,000. With B still at 338,000, A breaks even at a bonus of 26,000 paid within the period. The first question to ask is how A qualifies and pays out that bonus, especially whether the hire date could push it below the break-even amount. A verbal figure for prior staff can inform your follow-up. Leave your own amount unconfirmed until you get written terms that apply to you.
When HR replies, note the response date, where it is documented, and any unresolved condition beside each figure. If the email lists a 36,000 full-year target without the first-year proration method, leave 36,000 in the conditional column. If the conservative scenario is right at your minimum, ask whether HR can put a guaranteed minimum in writing or allow more time to decide. If one offer leads across your reasonable scenarios, it may be more useful to ask what you would work on, how you would commute, and what probation requires than to price out smaller benefits.
End by tracing each amount back to its first appearance. Is it already in monthly salary? Is it paid to you or into a specific account? Which months does it cover? When might it be clawed back? Keep the written amount and question together if any answer is missing. A breakdown you can verify is more useful than a single annual figure with no explanation.
A message you can send to HR
Hi, thank you for the offer. I'm checking compensation for my first 12 months and would appreciate clarification on four points.
① What is the monthly pre-tax base pay, how many months are paid at that rate, and is probation paid at the same rate? Are fixed allowances already included?
② Is there a guaranteed performance bonus, and what is the target? When is it paid and how is it prorated in the year I start? When is the signing bonus paid, and what would require repayment?
③ If equity is included, could you confirm the award type, number of units, first vesting date, and what happens if I leave? Please also note any conditions on expense benefits.
④ For the housing fund, where will it be filed, what base do you expect to apply, what are the employer and employee rates, when would contributions start, and how could they change? If any figures are estimates, please identify which ones. I'd like to review a written response or offer addendum before I decide.
Allow time for a reply. If the decision is due Friday afternoon, ask on Thursday for written confirmation that day on the two or three figures that could change your decision. Keep written attachments for terms that are already clear. If a term cannot be confirmed in time, retain both scenarios and compare against the conservative amount you can afford.
Ask whether the difference changes your plans
When cash is tight, set a minimum for a regular month's spendable pay and check whether probation and the first month fit your budget. If both offers clear that bar, weigh the housing fund alongside the work, commute, and daily arrangements. Start by distinguishing your career interests from your work values. If the work itself is the question, ask for a shareable example of a real assignment and try a small version of it before changing roles. Compare what you would do and how the team would work. If one offer adds rotating shifts or standby hours, use this shift-work and on-call offer checklist to compare schedule conditions separately. If you are still unsure what work you want, use the FermatMind 94-question career assessment to sort out your priorities.
If you want to understand who checks time records, fixed allowances, and payroll deductions, see what payroll and timekeeping clerks do. For your own offer, use the written terms and applicable contribution rules.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare total compensation when one offer has a bigger bonus? Add up fixed pay over the same period first. Compare a conservative scenario using guaranteed amounts and a second scenario using the written target, payment date, and eligibility terms. Compare equity by what is scheduled to vest in that period, and record any required repayment separately. A 13th-month payment belongs in fixed cash only if the written terms say you qualify within the comparison period.
What is the Beijing housing provident fund contribution base? It is the amount to which each contribution rate applies. Ask HR for the base they expect to file, each rate, and the first contribution month. Check these against the applicable Beijing contribution year. For an offer elsewhere, verify the rules at that offer’s contribution location before using any Beijing figures.
Can I compare take-home pay for offers in different cities? Ask each employer for an estimate for the same kind of regular pay month. Record pre-tax fixed cash, employee social insurance, employee housing fund contributions, and income tax separately under each city’s applicable rules. Use separate lines for a partial first month, a bonus month, or a signing payment. Employer housing fund contributions are account deposits, so compare them separately from the cash you can spend.


