Consider accepting the permanent role once you have enough authority, someone can take over your old work, and your first-month goals fit the time available. If you want to manage people but one of those conditions is unclear, propose a two-week acting assignment with a review date. If the company adds responsibilities without arranging a handoff, ask for the resources you need or put the decision on hold. Confirm pay, grade, and the effective date before you decide, so your plans don’t depend on a verbal “we’ll talk about it later.”
If you already want the job, say what would make it workable: “I’d like to take the role. To give the team the time it needs, I’d like to hand off the weekly reports and ad hoc data requests first. Who could take each one, and from what date? If we start with a two-week trial, can we set a review date today?” If you’re still deciding, try: “I’m interested in the opportunity. Could you share the first-month goals, decision authority, and handoff plan? I’ll give you an answer on Thursday.”
First, clarify what kind of offer you’re getting
| What you hear | What to confirm | How to respond on the spot |
|---|---|---|
| “We’re formally appointing you to lead the team next month” | Is there a clear plan for the role, authority, start date, evaluation, pay, and handoff? | Set up a meeting to confirm those details, then decide |
| “Lead the team for a while and we’ll see how it goes” | When does the acting assignment end? Which priorities can you change? If it doesn’t become a permanent role, who takes back your previous duties and when? | Agree only to an acting role with a defined scope and review date |
| “We’ll give you the title first. Your work stays the same” | Who is actually accountable for the new team deliverables? Does any of your current workload come off your plate? | Ask your manager to prioritize across the two sets of deliverables. Hold off if the workload can’t fit |
In one Chinese workplace report, a veteran advertising manager turned down the opportunity to lead an entire team and offered to mentor interns instead. In another report, an interviewee said her salary had stayed the same over more than two years of work, even though she had been promoted during that time. Those experiences suggest two questions: Am I being asked to coach a few people, or to own the whole team’s results? Who can confirm the pay, and when does it take effect? CCL’s resources for new managers address changes in peer relationships, delegation, and communication. Google’s internal research includes coaching and supporting development among managerial behaviors. Put those activities into a workweek and estimate the time they’ll take. 36Kr on why more people are turning down promotions · 36Kr on changing expectations of pay and promotion at major tech companies · CCL on challenges for first-time managers · Google re:Work manager research
Compare three workweeks: your current role, the two-week handoff, and the settled role
Fictional example. Zhou Ning works in operations analytics and is invited to manage three colleagues. Her manager wants the team to adopt a regular feedback schedule in the first month and keep delivering key dashboards on time. Zhou Ning has 40 hours to allocate each week. She breaks down the 24 hours she currently spends on her own deliverables: 12 hours for key dashboards and analysis, 2 hours for noncritical analysis, and 10 hours for recurring work she can hand off. Then she budgets separately for the transition and for a typical week once she has settled in.
| Time per week | Current role | First two weeks of handoff | After the handoff |
|---|---|---|---|
| Building dashboards and conducting analyses herself | 24 h | 12 h (noncritical analysis deferred) | 14 h |
| Reviewing the receiving colleague’s deliverables | 0 h | 2 h | 0 h |
| Technical reviews and cross-team communication | 8 h | 9 h | 9 h |
| Assigning work, coaching, and giving feedback | 2 h | 11 h | 11 h |
| Buffer time | 6 h | 6 h | 6 h |
| Total | 40 h | 40 h | 40 h |
The plan works if three conditions hold: someone takes over the 10 hours of recurring work and Zhou Ning spends only the 2 hours shown on reviewing it, her manager agrees to defer noncritical analysis for the first two weeks, and the colleague receiving the work has time for it. If that colleague can take only 4 hours a week, Zhou Ning retains 6 hours. With the rest of the plan unchanged, that makes the transition week 46 hours. Ask your manager to reset priorities: agree on what will be deferred, what can go to someone else, or when the appointment should begin. If you commit the entire buffer to routine work in advance, there’s no room left for surprises.
Next, ask what the colleague can do independently. They might be able to update the dashboard and document anomalies, while still needing Zhou Ning to review any change to how tracking events are defined. Reserve the 2 hours in each of the first two weeks for checks with clear acceptance criteria. Before dropping that review from the settled schedule, check at least once that the key dashboards have arrived on time and that anomalies have been handled.
Agree on the first month: goals, authority, and what happens if the trial ends
| What to confirm | What you can ask | Who confirms it, and when |
|---|---|---|
| Goals | “Which two outcomes matter most in the first month? If the handoff and urgent analysis requests conflict, which comes first?” | Your manager confirms goals and priorities before you accept |
| Decision authority | “Can I move low-priority requests to next week? If two departments both flag something as urgent, who makes the call?” | Someone authorized to delegate confirms the scope and escalation contact before the trial |
| Handoff | “Who takes the recurring reports and ad hoc requests? How will we sign off on the handoff and handle delays?” | Your manager and the receiving colleague confirm timing and capacity before work moves |
| Compensation | “What are the grade, fixed pay, variable pay terms, and effective date? For anything still undecided, who will get back to me and when?” | HR and an authorized manager confirm before formal appointment or before a change takes effect |
| Trial | “Who decides after two weeks? If I stay on the specialist track, how do my previous duties come back to me, and who tells the team?” | Your manager sets a review date and transition plan before the trial |
Put the five agreements on one first-month confirmation sheet, with one line per item:
Item (goals / authority / handoff / compensation / trial) / Agreement ___ / Confirmed by ___ / Reply due ___ / Effective date ___ / Conditions for continuing or handing back at the end of the trial ___
Send it to the people responsible for confirming each point. Ask your manager and the receiving colleague to check the handoff. Take questions about grade and pay to an authorized manager or HR. Mark anything still going through approval as pending, with a date for the next update.
If they say, “Do it for three months first and we’ll talk about a raise if it goes well”:
“I’m open to discussing an acting assignment. Can you and HR put the start and end dates, acting pay, evaluation criteria, and review date in writing? For this assignment, we could check whether the key dashboards were delivered on time and whether the scheduled feedback for all three colleagues happened as agreed. Who will sign off on those criteria at the review? Can we confirm the target grade or pay range, the approver, and the expected payroll period when any change would take effect? If approval is still pending, let’s decide that day whether to end the assignment or continue with a new deadline and terms.”
If a promotion changes duties, pay, or other terms already agreed in a labor contract, the applicable rules in China call for mutual agreement and a written amendment, with each party keeping a copy of the amended contract. Use the confirmation sheet or email to record the trial arrangement. Follow the separate formal process for changes to contract terms. Labor Contract Law of China, Articles 17 and 35
How to decide. In the example, Zhou Ning can accept as agreed once her manager confirms she can prioritize ad hoc requests, the colleague taking over has freed up time, and the first-month goals, pay, and effective date are confirmed in writing. If she has scheduling authority but the extra capacity isn’t available yet, she can discuss acting in the role for two weeks. If two acting duties take a combined 2 hours a week, for example, agree to defer the 2 hours of noncritical analysis and confirm that the current manager remains responsible for performance evaluations and formal approvals. If those 2 hours can’t be freed up, or the current manager can’t keep responsibility for evaluations and approvals, hold off on the acting assignment. If the work can be deferred but no one can take it over, hold off and discuss the next step on the specialist track. You might say: “Under the current split, the two roles add up to 46 hours a week. Can we first identify which tasks in those six hours can be deferred or handed off? Once we’ve done that, I can answer on Thursday.”
If you want to see whether you’d enjoy spending more of your time coordinating, coaching, or mediating, the 94-question FermatMind Career Assessment can help you sort out which work activities you prefer. Then try making a real schedule and giving feedback. You can use a one-task trial for an internal transfer to plan a trial and a guide to reflecting on leadership behaviors to record team feedback. The assessment gives you leads to explore. Appointment decisions and judgments about managerial ability need to take actual work, resources, and authority into account.
Frequently asked questions
Should I take the title if there’s no raise?
Check the added responsibilities, actual authority, and compensation review date, and decide which terms you can accept. If it’s an agreed two-week trial, write down your options when it ends. If it means formally doing both jobs long term, decide on the basis of the real workweek and the terms you’ve confirmed.
How do I talk to colleagues who used to be my peers?
Ask your manager to explain your role and authority to the team first. In your first conversation, clarify which scheduling decisions you own and what still follows the existing process. Ask the team what they most need resolved when priorities conflict.
Will my career stall if I don’t want to manage people?
Ask your manager to show you the duties, evaluation criteria, and actual promotion requirements for the next-level specialist role. Some organizations have a specialist track and others don’t. Check what’s available at your company.
References reviewed (editorial appendix)
| Original page | How this article uses it | What this article adds |
|---|---|---|
| 36Kr on why more people are turning down promotions | Chinese interviewees’ experiences of pressure, rewards, and personal choices | Turns those trade-offs into terms you can check before giving your answer |
| 36Kr on changing expectations of pay and promotion at major tech companies | Individual experiences with pay and limited power to reward others. No general conclusion | Distinguishes three kinds of offers and identifies the compensation details to confirm |
| CCL on challenges for first-time managers | Delegation, peer relationships, and changes in role | Budgets handoff hours for the transition and settled workweeks |
| Google re:Work manager research | Feedback, development, and collaboration can be observed | Includes those behaviors in acting assignments and team reviews, while leaving potential screening outside their purpose |


