The three fictional scenarios illustrate different ways of weighing the same options. Decisions on research involving people, data use, or consent follow the institution’s requirements and applicable ethics review.
Colleagues can share responsibility for choosing a direction. Discuss which criteria matter and what evidence supports each option.
INFJ and INTJ: setting the direction, and which condition gates it
In this fictional project, two colleagues have the same data, draft question, and authority. They need to decide whether the question matters to the people affected and whether the design can support the proposed inference.
One concern is whether the people affected would recognize the question as useful. Another is whether the same limits on inference apply to both proposed designs. Either person can raise both concerns. Evaluating an inference requires attention to the design and measurements. Sample size or use of secondary data alone cannot settle that question.
Write down who might use the findings and for what decision. Then state what the design can support and which claims would go beyond the data. Assign the checks according to relevant knowledge and confirm both before deciding.
Ask each colleague to explain why they would choose one proposal over another. Compare how they weighed usefulness to people and the conditions under which the claim would hold. This exercise describes one decision and has no score or typing rule.
INFJ and INTJ: co-writing a review, and whose paragraphs move
In this fictional review, both authors have the same draft, audience, and publication requirements. One proposed edit better acknowledges a concern readers may have. Another applies the same limits to comparable claims across the draft.
Both authors can assess how the edits affect readers and whether the claims are consistently qualified. The venue and the evidence help determine what the final draft needs.
Either author can adjust tone or revise a claim. The order of the edits does not establish T/F. Explain what the edit is meant to accomplish and which requirements it must meet.
INFJ and INTJ: half the budget is gone, one expense sheet
In this fictional budget cut, both researchers have the same expense sheet, deadlines, and record of commitments. They compare the same feasible changes using information about costs, participant follow-ups, and each item’s role in the design.
One concern is whether an option would break a commitment to participants. Another is whether every proposed change meets the same evidentiary threshold for the main claim. Either researcher can raise both. Existing obligations still apply.
Project stage, commitments, and available data guide the decision. Assign the checks to the people who know the participant arrangements and the design, regardless of type.