For a job offer in mainland China, check who recruits you, whose legal name goes on the employment contract, and which organization hosts and reviews your work. A posting can use a state-owned project name while a staffing agency signs the contract. Put both offers on the same timeline before comparing stability or growth.
Use the same period for both offers, starting with the first review cycle. Mark unresolved items “awaiting written confirmation.”
| Check | State-owned offer | Private offer |
|---|---|---|
| Organization named on the vacancy | ____ | ____ |
| Legal name of the contract signatory | ____ | ____ |
| Host organization and role | ____ | ____ |
| Contract term, review, and location | ____ | ____ |
| First deliverable, feedback, and training | ____ | ____ |
| Stability evidence: terms, reassignment, or written arrangements | ____ | ____ |
| Training, transfer, or rotation: approval and conditions | ____ | ____ |
Match the three names: Recruiter or posting organization → legal employer on the employment contract → host organization where you will work. Copy the original names exactly as written. The same organization may fill more than one role. If an offer omits a name, request written clarification.
Is this a direct hire or a labor dispatch arrangement?
Read the job posting, offer, graduate employment agreement if applicable, and draft employment contract together. Compare the recruiter named in the posting with the legal employer on the contract. Ask who will host the work and what the location and signing arrangements are. A recruiter affiliated with a group or outside company, or the use of a project brand, provides clues. Confirm the role against the contract and the actual arrangement.
Article 17 of mainland China's Labor Contract Law lists required terms including employer information, contract term, place and nature of work, pay, and social insurance. Under Article 58, the dispatch agency is the employer and must enter a fixed-term employment contract of at least two years with the dispatched worker. In addition to the Article 17 terms, the contract must identify the host organization, dispatch period, and role. Article 59 requires an agreement between the agency and the host organization. Labor Contract Law, State Administration for Market Regulation
The Xuanzhou District government published a labor dispatch notice for the district's state-owned capital operations group. The appointment and pay section says appointees sign employment contracts with a third-party human resources company. The notice mentions a one-year appointment. Ask what that period refers to and check the employment contract term and assignment period separately. Copy the full names of the advertiser, contract signatory, and host organization. Request written clarification and the relevant terms if they are unclear. Xuanzhou hiring notice · Dongguan labor dispatch handbook
If you are graduating and need an employment agreement, follow your university's current process for signing, cancellation, and reporting your graduate destination. Check the names on the university agreement and the arrangements for the future employment contract independently. If they conflict, ask both the university and the employer to clarify. Shandong Institute of Petroleum and Chemical Technology graduate guide
Compare two procurement assistant offers
In this fictional example, A places you on a local state-owned project and specifies an employment contract with a dispatch agency. You would file supplier documents. B comes directly from a private manufacturer. Its three-month training plan involves observing a round of quote collection, quote comparison, and checking goods into stock, with a mentor appointed by the procurement manager. Both offers use the same title.
- Stability. Ask A about the contract term, dispatch period, and who handles reassignment when the dispatch ends. Ask B what the role depends on, how it is evaluated, where you would normally work, and whether the team has changed recently. Ask both what deliverables you need to pass the first review.
- Growth. If A lets you compare actual quotes or evaluate suppliers and a mentor reviews that work, it can offer more than document filing. If B can identify the full quote task, a person in charge, and a feedback process, you can better assess the practice on offer. Mark a promise to cover the whole process in three months as unconfirmed if it comes without decision rights.
Suppose you need to stay in your city and want to complete one request for quotes independently within three months. Rule out offers that fail your location or transfer limits, then compare the tasks, responsibilities, and reviewers each can confirm. If A documents what happens when the project changes and gives you an equally verifiable training plan, your decision may change. If B gives you more autonomy, check whether the workload and resources are manageable.
Five questions to send to the recruiter
- What is the legal name of the organization that will sign my employment contract, and what is its role in this offer?
- Which organization and team will I work for? Where will I work, and whom will I report to?
- For labor dispatch, where will the contract list the position and dispatch period? Who handles the next steps at the end of the assignment?
- What deliverables will count in my first review? Who gives feedback and how often?
- Can you name a past training or rotation assignment, the person who would guide it, and when it would happen?
To compare affordability, make a separate table for fixed pay, comparable variable pay, and location costs. Check how mainland China's housing provident fund contribution base and rules apply. Keep the employment and business stability questions in your contract table. Compare total compensation and Beijing’s housing provident fund
Mark each item “documented,” “verbally stated,” or “unconfirmed.” If both offers meet your requirements for terms, location, and pay, compare the duties, growth opportunities, and risks you care about now. If you are also exploring your career direction beyond the contract, start with this related guide to choosing career-interest and personality tests · guide to testing work-environment preferences · 94-question career assessment
Frequently asked questions
The appointment says one year. Is that my employment contract term? Ask for the appointment or assignment period and the employment contract term in separate fields. The Xuanzhou notice in this article illustrates why the two need to be checked separately. The mainland China rule governing a labor dispatch agency’s contract is discussed above.
How do you record verbal answers and compare both offers in the same table?
Suppose a recruiter for a state-owned project says, “The project is stable, and you'll learn alongside the team,” while a private-company recruiter says, “There's room to grow quickly, and you'll need to adapt when the business changes.” Pick two conditions that would change your decision. For instance, you need to stay in your current city and want feedback on one procurement task in the first review cycle. Apply both conditions to both mainland China offers and keep the documents you've received, the exact clauses you can point to, and any answers still to be confirmed together.
For location, ask each recruiter, “Where would I primarily work after joining? If the project or business changes, who tells me, and which work locations might be involved?” If you have a draft contract, note the relevant clause. If the recruiter mentioned the address only on a call, log it as a verbal answer. When later materials arrive, check their dates and the contract signatory first, then find that same clause. If the documents list different addresses or organization names, put both versions side by side and ask the recruiter which one applies to this signing.
For development, ask each recruiter, “What can I complete on my own before the first review, and who will look at my work?” A procurement assistant might first shadow a request for quotes, then make a price comparison sheet independently and have the procurement manager review it. That gives you a task and a person who can give feedback. If they haven't set a schedule yet, ask when you can confirm it with your direct supervisor after joining. If they've only described a training goal, record it as such and revisit your assessment once the actual arrangements are available.
As the response deadline approaches, prioritize gaps based on their impact. If location affects your living arrangements, ask for it in writing first. For project details after joining, set a time to follow up. Send a brief message recapping your understanding, which document you need, and when you need a response. Put the same kinds of confirmed information in the same rows, then decide based on your own limits and the scope for growth in the work.
Once you have verified the employment terms, the Holland career interest assessment can help you explore which activities appeal to you. Check those interests against the actual work in each offer.


