Pick one recruitment notice for each job you might apply to. For a public-school teaching post with a staffing allocation, check the employment category, school level and subject, teaching qualification, and demo lesson. For a civil service position, check the role's eligibility requirements, common exam subjects, any specialist exam, and required service period. If a mandatory requirement is unclear, use the contact in the notice. If you're eligible for both, try sample questions and a demo lesson to compare the gaps and time commitment.
Start with your own situation
If you're unsure which work to compare, review the daily tasks of elementary school teachers →, then find a specific civil service position.
Key takeaways
- Look up the employment category in the attachments. A public school can recruit under several types of employment.
- Check eligibility before judging exam difficulty. See if you can apply, then find out where you struggle in a demo lesson or sample questions.
- Compare pay on the same basis. Calculate fixed cash, conditional cash, deductions, and account contributions separately.
Application decision worksheet
| What to enter | Teaching position | Civil service position |
|---|---|---|
| Organization, job code, employment category | ____ | ____ |
| Degree and major, eligible graduating cohorts | ____ | ____ |
| Certification or experience, service requirements | ____ | ____ |
| Supporting documents and application dates | ____ | ____ |
| Next step | Verify eligibility or practice a demo lesson | Verify eligibility or try sample questions |
Mark unconfirmed mandatory requirements “Check with recruiter.” Record whom to contact and the deadline. Compare preparation and compensation after confirming you can apply for both.
How can you tell whether a public-school teaching post has a staffing allocation?
For public-school teaching posts with a staffing allocation, check the employment category in the notice and its list of positions. For civil service posts, check the recruiting agency and the position's requirements. Use the job listing itself to confirm eligibility and employment status.
Public-school teachers in allocated posts in mainland China are hired under the public institution staffing and professional title systems. Civil servants in government agencies are managed under the civil service system. When you find a public-school post, record its job number alongside explicit wording such as “managed under the public institution staffing allocation system” (事业编制). Staffing quota, registered appointment, and contract employment must each be checked against the actual local notice. Similar labels can have different employment and compensation terms. If a notice merely says a school is hiring, find the attachment or contact the organization that issued it.
Try this with two Beijing notices. Applications for the Dongcheng District Education Commission's third 2026 public institution hiring round ran from November 9, 2026, at 10:00 to November 16 at 10:00. Applications for the Beijing 2027 civil service recruitment round ran from November 12, 2026, at 9:00 to November 18 at 18:00. These notices illustrate how to read the requirements. Use the positions, conditions, and dates for the round you're considering.
Suppose the major on your bachelor's diploma differs from the listing by two Chinese characters, and you also have a higher degree but plan to apply with your bachelor's. Enter “bachelor's degree only” and your actual highest degree on the worksheet. The Dongcheng example explicitly says people with a master's or doctorate can't apply as bachelor's degree holders to posts limited to a bachelor's. If another job says it accepts related majors but yours doesn't match the catalog, ask the recruiting body before the deadline using the exact name on your diploma. Record the reply and the job number it applies to. While waiting, prepare a backup you've confirmed you're eligible for and work to that deadline. The Beijing 2027 notice was issued in 2026. Check how each job defines recent-graduate eligibility. Read the qualifying graduation range in the listing.
Which is harder to prepare for, a demo lesson or the civil service written exam?
Compare specific positions and subjects. Check what it takes to reach the next stage, then do a set of sample questions and a demo lesson to find where you need preparation.
This round of Dongcheng teaching recruitment starts with a written exam, followed by a job competency assessment. Within that assessment, the demo lesson counts for 60% and the interview for 40%. The final score combines the written exam at 40% and the competency assessment at 60%. In an editorial example, a written score of 75, demo of 80, and interview of 70 give a competency score of 80 × 60% + 70 × 40% = 76 and a final score of 75 × 40% + 76 × 60% = 75.6. This round sets the qualifying mark at 60 for the written exam, the competency assessment, and the final score. Once candidates pass the written exam, its ranking determines who moves on to eligibility rechecks. In the Beijing civil service notice, the common exams are the administrative aptitude test and the written policy analysis exam (shenlun). Police posts at public security agencies require an additional specialist exam. If the target role has another professional skills test, check the job listing for details.
Application totals may include people still awaiting screening or people who never sat the exam. Record how many hires are planned, how many passed eligibility screening, how many took the exam, and how interviews are decided before comparing numbers. To assess your own preparation, try two actual tasks. Teach one concept and ask which example could confuse a student. Then answer sample questions from the syllabus and record whether you ran out of time, struggled with the material, or misunderstood the task. Try one on each of two evenings and start with the gap you can check most readily.
If you're eligible for both, how do you compare compensation?
Compare teaching and civil service pay in the same locality, career stage, and year. Separate fixed cash, performance-based items, employee deductions, and employer contributions to see what could change the result.
| Category | Details to record when asking about pay |
|---|---|
| Fixed cash | Post salary and salary-step pay for public-school teachers. Basic salary for civil servants as determined by position, rank, grade, and related factors |
| Conditional cash | Teacher performance pay and any applicable teaching seniority allowance. Applicable allowances, subsidies, and performance bonuses for civil servants |
| Deductions and contributions | Record what the employee pays and what the employer contributes separately. List housing provident fund account contributions separately |
| Payment conditions | Career stage, applicable locality, performance grade, payment cycle, and whether the amount is confirmed |
China's Ministry of Education explains public primary and secondary school post and performance pay in its response to recommendation No. 6833. Article 80 of the Civil Servant Law sets out the statutory categories of civil service basic salary, allowances, subsidies, and bonuses. Ask the appointing or recruiting organization to confirm the items and amounts for the specific job.
For compulsory education teachers, Article 31 of the Compulsory Education Law requires that their average pay be at least as high as the average pay of local civil servants. It compares group averages. For a particular job, verify the employment stage, fixed pay, and performance conditions.
Try these fictional figures. A earns a fixed 8,000 yuan before tax per month and B earns 7,500, each over 12 months. A's fixed cash totals 96,000 yuan and B's 90,000. B needs to qualify for a further 6,000 yuan to match A on annual pre-tax cash. If B will only work part of the year and the bonus is unconfirmed, update the period and the bonus conditions separately, then recalculate. Mark unconfirmed income “Ask” and use the actual posting for your decision.
Related reading
Once you have two compensation descriptions with their conditions, compare cash and housing fund contributions for the same year →
What two things should you ask about the work itself?
Look at the tasks you'll do often and the restrictions you would have to accept. Record classroom duties, service counter work, documentation, duty rotations, and minimum service alongside the relevant job.
For teaching, ask about work outside lessons each week and how the school assigns homeroom responsibilities, communication with families, and teaching development. For government work, ask who handles the service counter, documentation, coordination, or oversight for the position you're considering. Do a small exercise for each. Teach a concept and check whether the learner understood it. Or read a public service notice and explain who's eligible, what documents they need, the relevant date, and whom they can contact. Ask someone familiar with the work for feedback on the result.
The Beijing example requires newly recruited township civil servants to serve in the township for at least 5 years, including probation. Certain remote or hardship-area grassroots posts filled through policies that lower entry requirements have their own applicable service and transfer restrictions. Use the job code to find the conditions, then weigh the commute, family commitments, and minimum term. If the only job you qualify for has a condition you can't accept, look for another position in the same round or wait for a round you're clearly eligible for.
Frequently asked questions
Does a teaching certificate qualify me for a public-school position with a staffing allocation?
Check each listing's degree, major, school level, recent-graduate status, household registration, and work experience requirements. The notice for that round says whether supporting evidence can stand in for a certificate.
Can I prepare for teaching recruitment and the civil service exam at the same time?
Map out applications, exams, and appointment dates in two actual notices. Then try subject questions or a demo lesson for teaching, and aptitude or written policy analysis questions for civil service. If schedules or commitments conflict, use the rules for each round to choose.
Can a public-school teacher in an allocated post move directly into civil service?
Moving between systems may involve competitive recruitment or a formal transfer appointment. The route depends on the person, qualifications, position, and procedures at their current employer. Ask the personnel office which route applies to you.
Explore further
- Explore what you want in your day-to-day work. Compare activities and working conditions you'd be willing to take on. Open the FermatMind 94-question career assessment →
- Compare cash and contributions. Record both actual offers on the same basis. See how to compare total compensation →
- Test your interest in teaching. Pick a practice task from the work teachers do. View the elementary school teachers career profile →
Editorial review and methods
FermatMind Editorial. The notices apply to specific Beijing hiring rounds and can't be generalized to other regions. Scores and annual income are fictional calculations. They give no actual salary or pass-rate figures for the jobs. The career profile explains teaching tasks, and the career assessment helps you identify preferences.


